Should I Contact My Insurance After a Non-Fault Accident?

If you have been involved in a road traffic accident in London that wasn't your fault, your first instinct is likely to be to call your insurance provider. Most drivers do this because they believe it is the "correct" procedure. However, for a non-fault accident claimant, this is often the least efficient way to handle the situation.

While you have a contractual obligation to inform them, letting them handle the claim can lead to higher premiums, unnecessary excess payments, and a diminished settlement. This guide explains why you should be cautious when informing your insurer after a non-fault accident and outlines your alternatives.

Are You Required to Contact Your Insurer?

Most drivers believe that the first phone call after an accident must be to their insurance company. While your policy wording likely states you must "notify" them of any incident within 24 hours, you do not have to be the one to do it.

By contacting a specialist accident management company first, you protect yourself from the pitfalls of the standard claims process. Instead of you spending hours on hold with an insurance call centre, where you might accidentally say something that jeopardises your "non-fault" status, the AMC handles the communication for you.

This proactive approach ensures the incident is logged correctly as "Information Only," keeping your policy intact while you bypass the costs and restrictions of a standard insurance claim. Accident management vs insurance is the choice between protecting your financial position or losing your excess and benefits to an insurer's cost-saving protocols.

What Happens If You Do Contact Your Insurer?

Many drivers assume their premiums will increase or their no-claims bonus will be lost, but that isn’t always the case.

Whether your insurance is affected depends largely on how you choose to make your claim. Most insurers start the process of a standard insurance claim as soon as you report the accident. Even if you tell them you aren't at fault, they will treat the incident as an open file.

In most cases, the moment you report the accident, it is logged on the Claims and Underwriting Exchange (CUE). This database is shared among all UK insurers. Even if the case is closed with zero payout from your insurer, insurers view any involvement in an accident as an increased statistical risk and hence will likely increase your insurance premium.

Your insurer will likely direct you to their "approved repairer" network. You lose the ability to choose who fixes your car unless you pay an additional "out-of-network" excess fee.

Downsides of Claiming on Your Own Policy

If you choose to let your own insurer handle the claim rather than going after the at-fault driver's insurance directly, and want to know, “Will my insurance be affected?” Here is a guide on how claiming on your own policy will impact your insurance.

You Must Pay Your Excess

Even though you didn't cause the accident, your insurer will usually require you to pay your policy excess (e.g., £250–£500) to start repairs. They will promise to "recover" this from the other side later, but this can take months or even years if the other side disputes liability.

Also Read: Do I have to Pay Excess if the Accident Wasn’t My Fault

Impact on No Claims Bonus (NCB)

A No Claims Bonus (NCB) reduces your insurance premium for every consecutive year you drive without claiming on your own policy. It rewards safe driving with discounts that typically increase over five to nine years.

Your NCB may be temporarily suspended or reduced until your insurer successfully recovers 100% of the costs from the third party. If the third party is uninsured or untraceable, you could lose your NCB entirely, despite being the victim.

What Happens If You Use Accident Management Instead?

For a non-fault accident, using an accident management company (AMC) is often the superior route. A reliable AMC, such as Simple Claims, helps you return to the position you were in before the accident. We provide roadside recovery, a replacement vehicle, personal injury support, and handle your claim on a no-win, no-pay basis in case of a non-fault accident. 

No Excess to Pay

Because an AMC claims directly against the at-fault driver’s insurance policy, you never have to trigger your own policy. This means you don't have to pay a penny in excess.

Like-for-Like Replacement Vehicle

Unlike insurers, with a reliable car accident claim management company, you will be provided a credit hire vehicle that matches your own. If you drive a Mercedes, you get a Mercedes. If you drive a taxi or a delivery van, you get a plated vehicle that allows you to keep working. 

We provide a quick replacement vehicle at no upfront cost to you, and it is billed directly to the negligent party's insurer.

High Quality Repairs

AMCs typically allow you to choose your repairer. This ensures your car is fixed with high-quality parts at a garage that understands your specific make and model and provides insurance-approved repairs. It protects the vehicle’s resale value and warranty.

When Insurance Is the Right Option

While avoiding your own insurer is generally better for non-fault cases, there are specific scenarios where you should use them. If the accident was your fault, your insurer is the correct route. 

Moreover, if it is unclear who is at fault and the other driver is blaming you, your own insurer has the legal team to fight the case on your behalf. If you’re unsure, Simple Claims can review your situation and advise on the best next step.

Best Option for Non-Fault Accidents in London

London’s high traffic density and complex road layouts mean non-fault accidents are frequent. For drivers in London, the best strategy is to contact an accident management company before calling your insurer. Our team will help you with roadside recovery. Then, we will assess the accident to confirm 100% non-fault status.

This approach keeps your no-claim bonus intact, avoids out-of-pocket excess costs, and ensures you aren't downgraded to a tiny courtesy car while your vehicle is in the shop.

By claiming an accident through Simple Claims, instead of claiming against your own policy, the claim is handled directly against the at-fault driver’s insurer. This allows you to access the services you’re legally entitled to without using your insurance.

‍