Accident Management
vs
Insurance Company

If you’ve been involved in a non-fault road traffic accident in London, one of the first decisions you’ll face is whether to contact your insurance company or use an accident management company.

Claiming Through Your Insurance company

After an accident, your insurer may seem like the obvious first call. However, even when the accident wasn’t your fault, claiming through your own insurance can come with downsides.

What can happen if you claim through your insurer:

      You may need to pay your policy excess

      Your no-claims bonus may be affected

      Insurance premiums can increase at renewal

      Insurance premiums can increase at renewal

      Courtesy cars are often basic, limited, or delayed

      Repairs may be sent to cost-focused garages, not specialist       repair centres

     You may need to manage multiple parties yourself

Insurance companies are designed to protect their policies. They don't necessarily maximize your entitlements after a non-fault accident.

Claiming Through an Accident Management Company

An accident claims management company works differently.

Instead of claiming against your own policy, the claim is handled directly against the at-fault driver’s insurer. This allows you to access the services you’re legally entitled to without using your insurance.

How Simple Claims works

Simple Claims manages non-fault accident claims across London, handling everything from start to finish so you don’t have to.

Our service includes:

       Roadside recovery after an accident

       Like-for-like replacement vehicles

       Vehicle repairs and storage

       Personal injury support

       Full claims handling and insurer communication

Everything You Need to Manage Your Claim

Start your claim today with our expert team and in-house services, and get back on the road faster.

Start Your Claim
Service Comparison

Accident Management vs Insurance – Key Differences

The difference becomes clear when you compare how both options deal with a non-fault claim. The points below show how both options affect cost, convenience, and control.

Heading

Insurance

Accident Management

Cost

You may pay an excess and still see premium increases.

No upfront costs. No excess. Costs recovered from the at-fault insurer.

Replacement Vehicle

Often a basic courtesy car with limited availability.

A like-for-like replacement vehicle while your car is off the road.

Repairs

Repairs may prioritise cost over quality.

Repairs arranged through trusted, insurance-approved repair centres with manufacturer-approved parts.

Claims Handling

Repairs may prioritise cost over quality.

A dedicated claims handler manages everything for you.

Insurance Impact

Your policy is used, which may affect your record.

Your insurance policy remains untouched.

Read more on 👉 Will my insurance be affected after a non-fault accident?

Which Option Is Right for You?

If the accident was your fault, your insurer is the correct route.

If the accident was not your fault, using an accident management company is usually the better option, especially if:

  • You want to avoid paying excess
  • You need a replacement vehicle quickly
  • You want to protect your no-claims bonus
  • You don’t want to deal with insurers and paperwork

When Accident Management Is the Right Option

Accident management is suitable if:

  • The accident was non-fault
  • Your vehicle is damaged or undriveable
  • You need a replacement vehicle quickly
  • You want to avoid using your insurance policy

For confirmed non-fault claims, Simple Claims offers clear advantages and full end-to-end support.

How Simple Claims Makes It Easier

Simple Claims provides London-wide accident support with an in-house team. One point of contact manages everything from repair coordination to replacement vehicles, ensuring a fast, smooth recovery.

Need Accident Recovery?

Start your claim today with our expert team and in-house services, and get back on the road faster.

Start Your Claim

Frequently Asked Questions

How quickly will I get a replacement vehicle?

In most cases, we can deliver a like-for-like replacement within 24 hours of your claim being approved.

What happens if my vehicle needs repairs?

Your car will be repaired in our own insurance-approved garage using manufacturer-approved parts.

What is car accident claims management?

Car accident claims management means handling everything after a non-fault accident from recovery, insurance, repairs, replacement vehicles, to full compensation. All managed on your behalf.

Do I have to pay anything upfront?

No. There are no upfront costs, and we operate with no hidden fees or excess charges.

Do you cover all areas in the UK?

We currently support drivers across Greater London. If you’re unsure whether your location is covered, our team can confirm this when you contact us.

Will my No Claims bonus be affected?

No. Your No Claims bonus is protected, and your insurance record stays safe.

Ready to Get Back on the Road?

With over 20 years of experience, 600+ replacement cars, and a dedicated in-house team, we make the process simple, fast, and stress-free.
Get Started Today